How to choose an egg donor: what matters, and what can wait

Short answer

Start with what protects your future child: the donor's health, family history and genetic carrier screening, checked against the sperm provider. Then consider whether she's open to future contact, whether she's available fresh or frozen, and cost. Personal traits come last, and it helps to decide your few must-haves before you browse.

Not legal or medical advice. This guide is general information, checked against the sources listed below as of November 15, 2026. Laws and clinic policies change. Talk to a licensed attorney in each country and state involved, and to your clinic, before you sign anything.

Where should I start?

With your must-haves, written down before you open a single profile. Most people find two or three true deal-breakers and a longer list of nice-to-haves. Without them, the volume of profiles becomes overwhelming.

What matters most medically?

Health and family history. ASRM recommends that donors provide a detailed three-generation family history, reviewed by a genetic counselor or similarly qualified professional (ASRM, 2024).

Genetic carrier screening. ASRM recommends pan-ethnic expanded carrier screening over ethnicity-based panels, and suggests offering carrier screening to the recipient's reproductive partner, so the sperm provider's results can be compared with the donor's (ASRM, 2024). If you're two fathers, this can influence whose sperm you use.

Age. ASRM says oocyte donors should preferably be 21 to 34, and that a donor over 34 should have her age disclosed to recipients as part of informed consent (ASRM, 2024).

More in our screening guide.

What about future contact?

Decide early whether you want a donor who is open to identity disclosure or contact later. ASRM's Ethics Committee supports telling children about their donor conception (ASRM, 2018), and ASRM now says "nonidentified" rather than "anonymous," because anonymity can't be promised in the era of consumer DNA testing (ASRM, 2022). If you live outside the U.S., your country may require an open-identity donor (Netherlands example). See known vs. anonymous donors.

What practical factors matter?

  • Availability: fresh cycle, frozen lot, or both. See fresh vs. frozen.
  • Donation history: prior cycles and outcomes.
  • Cost: compensation and fees vary. See egg donor cost.

And the personal traits?

Ancestry, looks, education, interests, the voice in her essay. These matter, and it's fine that they do. Many people look for a donor who resembles a non-genetic parent, or whose values feel familiar. Just keep them in proportion to the medical and practical basics.

How do I keep a shortlist that holds up?

Keep everything in one place, with a short note on why you liked each donor. Revisit your list after a few days; first impressions shift. If you're a couple, review separately first. See choosing an egg donor as a couple. Dotis is built for this: every donor from the agencies you use in one deck, your yes, no or maybe one at a time, and a ranked shortlist with notes.

Frequently asked questions

What should I look for in an egg donor?

Start with health, family history and carrier screening, then openness to contact, availability and cost, then personal traits.

What age should an egg donor be?

ASRM says donors should preferably be between 21 and 34.

Should the egg donor look like me?

Many people prefer it, especially the non-genetic parent, but it's a personal choice and less important than health and screening.

How long does it take to choose an egg donor?

It varies. Writing your must-haves first and keeping one shortlist tends to make it faster and calmer.

Sources

Sources were checked on November 15, 2026. If you spot something out of date, tell us when you request access.