Choosing an egg donor as a couple: how to decide together without pressure

Short answer

Agree on a few must-haves together, then review donors separately so neither partner sways the other. Compare the donors you both liked, talk openly about what matters to the non-genetic parent, and check carrier screening against the sperm provider. Decide together, and give it time; a short, shared list is easier than a long one.

Not legal or medical advice. This guide is general information, checked against the sources listed below as of November 15, 2026. Laws and clinic policies change. Talk to a licensed attorney in each country and state involved, and to your clinic, before you sign anything.

Why is choosing together so hard?

Because it's a big decision, made with two sets of feelings and often a long history behind it. One partner may be the genetic parent and the other not. One may care deeply about resemblance, the other about health history or openness to contact. And when you browse side by side, the more confident voice can quietly decide for both of you.

How should we start?

Agree on must-haves first. Sit down before you look at profiles and agree on two or three deal-breakers, such as screening standards, openness to future contact, or availability (fresh or frozen). Write them down. Anything else is a preference you can trade.

Should we look at donors together or apart?

Apart first, then together. When each of you says yes, no or maybe privately, your first reactions stay honest. Then you compare the donors you both liked. This is how Dotis works for couples: each partner reviews donors on their own phone, a donor becomes a Match when you both like her or either of you super-likes her, and then you review your matches together, rank them and decide who to contact.

What about the non-genetic parent?

Give that partner's feelings real weight. For two fathers, only one is usually the genetic father of each child; see whose sperm, whose embryos. For two mothers, reciprocal IVF is one option, but if neither partner's eggs are used, both may be non-genetic mothers. Many couples look for a donor who resembles the non-genetic parent, or whose story resonates with them. Some find a counselor helpful; ASRM's guidance recommends psychoeducational counseling for recipients of donated gametes (ASRM, 2024).

How does carrier screening affect the choice?

ASRM recommends expanded carrier screening for donors and offering it to the recipient's reproductive partner (ASRM, 2024). If the donor and the intended sperm provider carry the same condition, your clinic may suggest a different donor or a different sperm provider. Get both results early, before anyone falls in love with a profile.

What if we disagree?

It's normal. Try:

  1. Going back to your written must-haves.
  2. Each naming one donor you'd be comfortable with, even if she isn't your favorite.
  3. Taking a few days. First impressions change.
  4. Asking what's behind a preference: a worry about health, about resemblance, about the child's future questions.

Should we tell our child about the donor?

ASRM's Ethics Committee supports disclosing donor conception to children (ASRM, 2018). Talking about this together now can shape whether you choose an open-identity donor. See known vs. anonymous donors.

Frequently asked questions

How do couples choose an egg donor together?

Agree on must-haves, review separately, then compare the donors you both liked and decide together.

What if my partner and I like different donors?

Return to your shared must-haves, take time, and discuss what's behind each preference.

Should the donor look like the non-genetic parent?

Many couples prefer that. It's a personal choice; health and screening come first.

Do both partners need carrier screening?

ASRM recommends offering carrier screening to the partner providing sperm, so results can be compared with the donor's.

Sources

Sources were checked on November 15, 2026. If you spot something out of date, tell us when you request access.