Known, open-ID or anonymous egg donor: what each really means now
Short answer
A directed (known) donor is someone you identify, often a friend or relative. A nonidentified (anonymous) donor is chosen from a database without names. Open-identity donors agree to be identifiable to the child later. Experts now say anonymity cannot be guaranteed because of consumer DNA testing.
Not legal or medical advice. This guide is general information, checked against the sources listed below as of November 15, 2026. Laws and clinic policies change. Talk to a licensed attorney in each country and state involved, and to your clinic, before you sign anything.
What do the terms mean?
In 2022 ASRM recommended new terms: directed (identified) donors instead of "known", and nonidentified donors instead of "anonymous" (ASRM, 2022). The change reflects reality: a donor whose name you don't know may still be identifiable.
- Directed donor: someone you choose and know, such as a friend or relative.
- Nonidentified donor: a donor you choose from an agency, egg bank or clinic database, without identifying details.
- Open-identity (open-ID) donor: a nonidentified donor who agrees that the child can learn her identity, often at 18.
- Open or semi-open arrangements: some agencies offer a meeting or ongoing contact if both sides agree.
Can an egg donor stay anonymous?
Not reliably. The ABA's 2026 review says the legal community broadly accepts that anonymous donation is "effectively over," and that donors are told anonymity "simply can't be guaranteed." It notes California law on releasing identifying donor information to adult donor-conceived people, and that the Uniform Parentage Act of 2017 asks clinics to keep donor identifying information for access at 18 (ABA, 2026).
Other countries go further. Since May 4, 2020, Ireland requires traceable donors in donor-assisted reproduction (gov.ie). The Netherlands has banned anonymous donation since June 1, 2004, and its government calls the use of anonymous donors abroad "undesirable" (Rijksoverheid). If you live abroad, this can affect recognition at home. See our country guides.
What do experts recommend telling the child?
ASRM's Ethics Committee "strongly encourages" telling donor-conceived people about their conception, while leaving the choice to parents, and asks programs to store donor medical and genetic information permanently (ASRM, 2018).
What are the pros and cons of a directed donor?
A friend or relative can mean a shared family history and less searching. It also means a lifelong relationship to plan for, separate legal agreements and counseling. ASRM has an Ethics Committee opinion on family members as donors or carriers and finds it acceptable when everyone is fully informed and counseled. Have both sides represented by their own attorneys.
How do I decide?
Ask yourself:
- Would I want my child to be able to find their donor one day?
- Does my home country require identifiable donors?
- How much contact am I comfortable with, now and later?
Then filter your search by it. In most donor databases, openness is listed on the profile. In Dotis, it's one of the facts you can choose to read first on every card.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a known and an anonymous egg donor?
A known (directed) donor is someone you identify yourself. An anonymous (nonidentified) donor is chosen from a database without names. ASRM now recommends the terms directed and nonidentified.
Can egg donors remain anonymous forever?
Not reliably. Consumer DNA tests and new state laws mean anonymity cannot be guaranteed, according to the ABA's 2026 review.
What is an open-ID egg donor?
A donor who agrees that the child may learn her identity later, often at 18. Agencies and egg banks list this on the profile.
Do some countries ban anonymous egg donation?
Yes. Ireland and the Netherlands require identifiable donors for treatment there, and the Dutch government discourages anonymous donors abroad.
Sources
- Updated terminology for gamete and embryo donors: directed (identified) and nonidentified, ASRM, 2022
- Charting the New Legislative Frontier in Assisted Reproduction, ABA, Nov 15, 2026
- Informing offspring of their conception by gamete or embryo donation, ASRM, 2018
- Children and Family Relationships Act 2015, Government of Ireland
- Draagmoederschap in het buitenland, Rijksoverheid (Netherlands)
- Kan ik als spermadonor of eiceldonor bezwaar maken tegen het doorgeven van mijn gegevens?, Rijksoverheid
Sources were checked on November 15, 2026. If you spot something out of date, tell us when you request access.